Well...I live in a really atheist area of California so...Never once seen a religious person ever ask me anything

ya i guess that would do it. nice name btw

But why should they be punished?
All they've done is something they enjoy.

but other people dont enjoy it. if someone endangers other peoples lives it benefits more people to punish the wrong doer.

But the person won't enjoy his punishment.
I don't enjoy school. Who decides what's right and wrong?
why?

that's why i said if it benefits the majority of people.
the government decides what's right and what's wrong. the government is the voice of the people, so the people decide what is right.

How do you decide who should be punished?
Some people enjoy things, other people don't.
Say, abortion. Who should be punished, the people offended by abortion, or the people offended by the people offended by abortion?

its not a crime to be offended by something. people are allowed their own beliefs and opinions, in fact it is supported. we decide who gets punished by making laws as i explained in #86. everyone, religious and non religious, agree on the laws by voting.

And who are they to decide who's unbalanced and who isn't?

From my worldview, murder is bad because it ends an innocent life, and life is sacred.
There is no sanctity of life if there is no supernatural. It doesn't work.

they decide through a little thing called the justice system. either an unbiased third person reviews all the evidence and makes a decision or a jury of people come to a decision.

i'm assuming you believe in some sort of after life and that death is just another step in your journey, so why does it matter when you arrive at that step?

But why should they be punished?
All they've done is something they enjoy.

but other people dont enjoy it. if someone endangers other peoples lives it benefits more people to punish the wrong doer.

I'm not asking about my morals, I'm trying to understand what yours are.
So by that standing, what right does the government have to jail someone for rape?

you didn't ask about your morals, but i did. answer the question.
the government helps protect the people from unbalanced people by removing them from the general population. by removing one persons rights, they protect a larger number of peoples well-being.

But the person won't enjoy his punishment.
I don't enjoy school. Who decides what's right and wrong?
why?

that's why i said if it benefits the majority of people.
the government decides what's right and what's wrong. the government is the voice of the people, so the people decide what is right.

How do you decide who should be punished?
Some people enjoy things, other people don't.
Say, abortion. Who should be punished, the people offended by abortion, or the people offended by the people offended by abortion?

its not a crime to be offended by something. people are allowed their own beliefs and opinions, in fact it is supported. we decide who gets punished by making laws as i explained in #86. everyone, religious and non religious, agree on the laws by voting.

And who are they to decide who's unbalanced and who isn't?

From my worldview, murder is bad because it ends an innocent life, and life is sacred.
There is no sanctity of life if there is no supernatural. It doesn't work.

they decide through a little thing called the justice system. either an unbiased third person reviews all the evidence and makes a decision or a jury of people come to a decision.

i'm assuming you believe in some sort of after life and that death is just another step in your journey, so why does it matter when you arrive at that step?

But why should they be punished?
All they've done is something they enjoy.

but other people dont enjoy it. if someone endangers other peoples lives it benefits more people to punish the wrong doer.

In your own words.

bad = not good

Bad. What is bad? Explain to me exactly what "bad" is and why it is "bad".

Definition of BAD

1
a : failing to reach an acceptable standard : poor <a bad repair job>
b : unfavorable <make a bad impression>
c : not fresh : spoiled <bad fish>
d : not sound : dilapidated <the house was in bad condition>
2
a : morally objectionable : evil <bad men>
b : mischievous, disobedient <a bad dog>

2. a) is the most relevant one.

But why should they be punished for it?

they did something bad and need to learn the error of their ways, or else be taken out of the general population.

If you enjoy killing and raping, why not do it?

well, they do and they get punished. that question had nothing to do with anything.