I thought it was quite amazing, and I don't have any ill words to say against it. Peter Jackson did a perfect job, and of course he couldn't do everything to the way Tolkien wrote it... I think it was fantastic.
there were only two real flaws i found. i also thought it was amazing!
i'm gonna ask for your thoughts on something; is it meant to be filmed as bilbo baggins wrote his book?
I believe so, I think it's more of a way to tie Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit together... so I believe it's easier for people to understand. He's writing There and Back Again and he's thinking back on the adventure which tells the story of The Hobbit.
thankyou. i ask this because i got confused when gandalf and saruman were having that conversation and bilbo was unaware of what was being said, but was still able to write about it.