the dead sea scrolls

I believe you're thinking about Russels Teapot, not occams razor. russels teapot is about believing things without evidence. Occams razor says that given 2 explanations for the same thing, that the less complex should be the accepted one.

Senario: asked to guess a number between 1 and 10. I guess 7 and I'm right.

Solution A: I were lucky and had a 10%chance.
Solution B: Magic flying invisible Gnomes used their psychic powers to read the guys mind, then came over and whispered the answer in my ear.

Occams razor just says you should probably pick solution A.

there will always be this debate, so why bother. They both just want to feel right.

have a dancing anime girl.

Your gift has been accepted. Here is a present in return.