| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Show:   Top Rated Newest Per page:
Order:
Show All Replies
User avatar #142 - crazyhindu (01/22/2013) [-]
what if, now bear with me here, what if we haven't come in contact with alien beings because they are at the same technological standpoint we are at and are wondering why they haven't been contacted by aliens yet
#138 - N. Korean citizen (01/22/2013) [-]
if i found a planet full of animals id definitely wanna go check that shit out
User avatar #135 - rdangerdash (01/22/2013) [-]
Are the aliens rally that smart though? I mean, they came to an alien planet with a vast array of creatures they have never seen before and decided that it wasn't worth their time. What is intelligent about abandoning the quest for knowledge?
#132 - N. Korean citizen (01/22/2013) [-]
Funny how FJ eats up anything that Neil deGrasse Tyson says without questioning a single thing.
#162 to #132 - N. Korean citizen (01/22/2013) [-]
How is that funny?
#136 to #132 - robopuppy (01/22/2013) [-]
I'm sorry, what were you saying? I was too busy being drawn in by his mustache.
#131 - N. Korean citizen (01/22/2013) [-]
or maybe we're the first species to be this advanced and all the other alien races are just tiny microbes and bacteria waiting to evolve into something of higher value.
User avatar #128 - kanatana (01/22/2013) [-]
All respect to Neil, any passing intelligent species would be able to detect the QUADRILLIONS of gigs of raw data leaving Earth in the form of radio signals every hour, and if they stopped by Earth, they would see the obvious signs of life on its surface.
User avatar #141 to #128 - mesues (01/22/2013) [-]
Life, not intelligence
User avatar #150 to #141 - kanatana (01/22/2013) [-]
Again, the raw information and obvious signs of civilization would be sufficient. For instance, if they were passing by on the night side of Earth, they would see the lights of civilization from space-- assuming they "see" the same as we do, of course.
User avatar #167 to #150 - mesues (01/22/2013) [-]
Still doesnt mean theyd want to talk to us. Think of an advanced version of the worm metaphor. They may see us as intelligent, but not intelligent enough to bother with
User avatar #168 to #167 - kanatana (01/22/2013) [-]
Hey, I didn't say they'd WANT to talk to us. They could be indifferent for all we know. But the point is, they'd RECOGNIZE us. Realize that we were here. And if we really are ants to them... well, a swarm of ants could pick a leopard to the bone in minutes, and humans are warriors. We are THE piranha of the universe.
User avatar #169 to #168 - mesues (01/22/2013) [-]
Nukes aint shit if they got a death star
User avatar #171 to #169 - kanatana (01/22/2013) [-]
Yeah, but a small torpedo blew that fucker up...
User avatar #178 to #171 - mesues (01/22/2013) [-]
We dont exactly have a battalion of space fighters. The only thing weve gotten into space are metal tubes strapped to rockets
User avatar #184 to #178 - kanatana (01/22/2013) [-]
Ha. Please. It took us less than ten years to put guns on airplanes. Forty years after that, we went to space. Ten years or so after that, we went to the moon. You really think it'll take too long before we have mini rockets with rockets on them?
User avatar #187 to #184 - mesues (01/22/2013) [-]
Well im assuming thats what nasa is working on, maybe not guns, but idgaf
User avatar #270 to #187 - Kaoz **User deleted account** (01/22/2013) [-]
nope nasa is just about dont but other private companies are working on it, just saying
User avatar #173 to #171 - Kaoz **User deleted account** (01/22/2013) [-]
but they had the same level of technology
User avatar #179 to #173 - kanatana (01/22/2013) [-]
You're the one that brought nukes and the Death Star up, two things that I know enough about. Now, listen here-- once you split the atom, you really don't have that far up the technological food chain to go. Sure, you can make them bigger and more efficient, but the basic technology will always be the same. The for has retained its shape for centuries now. Newtonian physics have remained constant for centuries. And let me tell you something-- any alien species that comes close enough for us to blow up WILL be blown up; if we want them to die, there really isn't anything that can keep us from going Ender Wiggen on them.
User avatar #263 to #179 - Kaoz **User deleted account** (01/22/2013) [-]
independence day, we launched a nuke at that that did jack shit to the ships. i kow it was all fake but still the level of tech they had how do we know an atomic weapon would do any actual harm
User avatar #264 to #263 - kanatana (01/22/2013) [-]
There is no known material in this world, known or theoretical, known to be able to survive a nuclear blast, period. Without some sort of energy shield, a nuke would do at least some damage. I guarantee it.
User avatar #269 to #264 - Kaoz **User deleted account** (01/22/2013) [-]
thats what i mean if they have some sort of energy field surrounding it a nuke wouldnt harm them at all
User avatar #272 to #269 - kanatana (01/22/2013) [-]
Depends on the energy field.. but really, talking about that delves into science fiction, not speculative science.
User avatar #273 to #272 - Kaoz **User deleted account** (01/22/2013) [-]
well not just shields but im sure they have devices and weapons that can defeat nuclear missiles,
easy such as a laser weapon that explodes the missile in flight before detonation
User avatar #274 to #273 - kanatana (01/22/2013) [-]
It's far more likely that any ship going through deep space would have a hull engineered to absorb/dissipate physical attacks or damage, actually. But the blast from a nuke at short range would still most likely vaporize it. Just saying.
User avatar #290 to #274 - Kaoz **User deleted account** (01/22/2013) [-]
solar flares is what i was trying to think of, unshielded those can severly any objects in the vacuum of space
User avatar #289 to #274 - Kaoz **User deleted account** (01/22/2013) [-]
but it would also likely be designed to absorb/dissipate all kinds of radiation as well depending how close they pass by stars or solor radiation, storms and many other forms
User avatar #301 to #289 - kanatana (01/22/2013) [-]
Radioactive damage is entirely different from concussive damage.
User avatar #159 to #150 - Kaoz **User deleted account** (01/22/2013) [-]
if you walk by an ant hill and see signs of civilization are you gonna stop to observe? are you going to detect the pheromones the ants admit and take it for intelligence?
User avatar #165 to #159 - kanatana (01/22/2013) [-]
Ants don't have the capacity for higher learning. Humans do. Once you get high enough in the theoretical evolutionary chain, species across the board will almost inevitably had some parallels in the process. Radio, digital transmission, thermal signatures, etc, will be universal signs of intelligence. There is almost no way that a species that comes close enough to Earth will do so accidentally, and if they see us, they'll certainly see or detect artificial satellites in orbit.
#174 to #165 - drroxxo (01/22/2013) [-]
Why would you want to be in contact with a species that is constantly at war with itself? What if they got ahold of your tech and decided to attack you with it? I wouldn't venture too close to us if I were them either.
User avatar #180 to #174 - kanatana (01/22/2013) [-]
Well, why not? Peace, love, blah blah. There's dozens of ways THAT particular scifi trope could be played out.
User avatar #172 to #165 - Kaoz **User deleted account** (01/22/2013) [-]
your walking through a forest and you have an iphone, if you see someone using a walkie talkie does that mean your going to interact with him. he has intelligence and youve never seen him before but that doesn't mean you want to be friends.
User avatar #175 to #172 - kanatana (01/22/2013) [-]
No, but I'll put the fucking phone down and ask for directions out of the fucking forest.
#186 to #175 - seantommy (01/22/2013) [-]
I think the major point here that you are missing (and that has been lost in this debate) is the idea that alien life COULD indeed detect us, but be so much more advanced than us that our current level of civilization and technology are trivial to them. For ants to create such a complex home as an ant hill clearly indicates intelligence, and knowledge of some form of architecture. That doesn't mean that they're significant enough for us to stop and study. If aliens of that much greater intelligence/more advanced technology found us, they could, and would, have far greater problems to deal with. Yes, ants show signs of intelligence. Yes, there is merit to studying them. We can also teach rudimentary sign language to monkeys. That doesn't mean it's high on our agenda.
User avatar #198 to #186 - kanatana (01/22/2013) [-]
That's a fair, logical, and well-thought out point, and I agree with you. But that DOESN'T mean that we are ants to any passing alien species. Conservative estimates of our growth as a species show us getting out of the solar system within two hundred years or so. We aren't that far behind anything else out there, really.

Basically, to sum up this entire thread, Ender's Game.
#201 to #198 - seantommy (01/22/2013) [-]
Thumb for you for the Ender's Game shout out. I adhere to the belief that the chances of two separate intelligent species existing in the universe close enough together in space and time to actually communicate are astronomically small, and so we probably are, as far as "intelligent life" goes, alone in the universe. We can hope, though :)
User avatar #262 to #201 - Kaoz **User deleted account** (01/22/2013) [-]
but if the aliens can travel through galaxy's i doubt their all that impressed by us getting out of our solar system, which we do have probes past that boundary already
User avatar #204 to #201 - kanatana (01/22/2013) [-]
As long as we don't Little Doctor each other... Yeah.
#183 to #175 - drroxxo (01/22/2013) [-]
And then he starts playing a banjo.
User avatar #185 to #183 - kanatana (01/22/2013) [-]
/thread.
#126 - N. Korean citizen (01/22/2013) [-]
they could anytime put us in a bucket of water and see what happens
#124 - ronyx (01/22/2013) [-]
I'll pay more attention to worms, when they have built space rockets, nukes, advanced medicine, hookers, computers, androids, etc. Aliens would probably not pay attention to us if we were still cavemen, but now we have all these technology we have achieved so they would indeed acknowledge us.
#147 to #124 - archoninterface (01/22/2013) [-]
Hookers XD
User avatar #127 to #124 - Keleth (01/22/2013) [-]
our science could look like caveman science to them
#117 - bendingeffects (01/22/2013) [-]
And what minimal intelligence they observed is rapidly disappearing.
And what minimal intelligence they observed is rapidly disappearing.
User avatar #116 - stizz **User deleted account** (01/22/2013) [-]
I think this is a great idea, and not to discredit Neil at all, I love the dude BUT

We would at least acknowledge the worm's existence....we recognize the fact that a worm is there, moving, inching it's way along doing its wormy business.

You really think an alien race would pass us by, notice we have life that is at least somewhat intelligent, and just go on its way? No, they would at least acknowledge our existence too.
User avatar #118 to #116 - Zeigh (01/22/2013) [-]
How often do you personally acknowledge the existence of a worm?
Sure you know they're there, but honestly, when was the last time you went around, looking for every little thing that moves and attempted to understand what they do and whether or not they're intelligent.
Aliens could just be flittin' on down to Alpha Centauri for the big party and think this is just some po dink place in the back water of the universe. They might think, "Oh hey, there's shit moving around on that little blue speck...meh, that party's gonna be pretty sweet."
User avatar #122 to #118 - stizz **User deleted account** (01/22/2013) [-]
No, I think an intelligent life form (some alien race) would acknowledge another intelligent life form's existence (us).
User avatar #129 to #122 - Zeigh (01/22/2013) [-]
You're assuming another intelligent life form would deem us as another intelligent life form.
What didn't you get about Neil's argument up there?
Assuming for a moment that there were a vastly superior life form orbiting the Earth right now. It's civilization got to a point where it can cross at the very least intergalactic expanses in a relatively short amount of time and make this voyage at least twice (to and from).
Why would it think this place had intelligent life?
User avatar #133 to #129 - stizz **User deleted account** (01/22/2013) [-]
That isn't what I'm assuming.
Life period, I don't think an alien life form would see the amount of life we have here on Earth and pass it up.
User avatar #139 to #133 - Zeigh (01/22/2013) [-]
Why not?
Statistically speaking there are bound to be hundreds if not thousands of millions of planets with enormous ecosystems full of life at every corner, doesn't mean they're smart or that you should stop unless they have some purely scientific goal in mind in which case they might catalogue and do a little research.
Another thing. Why would they even stop here unless it were on route to their destination?
User avatar #143 to #139 - stizz **User deleted account** (01/22/2013) [-]
Dude who said anything about stopping here? You're getting off topic lol.
I just really don't think an alien race would pass us up. I think they would make some form of acknowledgement or communication or something.
User avatar #149 to #143 - Zeigh (01/22/2013) [-]
"I don't think an alien life form would see the amount of life we have here on Earth and pass it up."
M'kay.
Why would you communicate with a worm?
You're missing the whole point here entirely dude.
#158 to #149 - N. Korean citizen (01/22/2013) [-]
I think the problem is when we use the word "intelligent life" we think of the definition of intelligence as defined by how smart we are. I think when dealing with other life forms we consider "intelligence" to mean consciousness, a trait that makes us humans so much more special than any other species we know of.

Surely an alien race will not pass up the opportunity to contact another CONSCIOUS species, because although we may not be as evolved as them, we can still acknowledge them as another conscious being. Our minds could never be equivalent to a worm on any scale.
User avatar #152 to #149 - stizz **User deleted account** (01/22/2013) [-]
Like I just said, they could communicate or acknowledge us, they don't have to land here.....
And no I'm not missing the point. I disagree, and think an alien race would not just zip right past us.
User avatar #155 to #152 - Zeigh (01/22/2013) [-]
I didn't say anything about landing, I said stop, that could mean in orbit, that could mean just close enough for whatever scanning device, w/e.
You're still assuming that we're worth receiving attention.
What Neil is postulating is that whatever aliens are possibly observing are think we're nothing more than worms, just a background life form not really worth their attention.
You still haven't answered my question of why an alien would stop and ponder the existence of humans.
User avatar #157 to #155 - stizz **User deleted account** (01/22/2013) [-]
Alright lol I honestly don't even care anymore.
Have a good one dude
User avatar #114 - lolollo (01/22/2013) [-]
Except that we only act that way because we know pretty much everything we'd want to know about worms, but before then, yes we did have interst in it. We picked it up, prodded it, even dissected it in our biology classes until we learned all we were interested in about worms. Only after that did we start acting like worms weren't worth the effort to pay attention to it. So yes, I do believe aliens HAVE studied us simply because it's what we would do, and have done to things that we found new.

Then again, it's also possible that these aliens could've studies us in a way that we wouldn't comprehend, making it where we would never know we were being studied.
User avatar #113 - nadastress (01/22/2013) [-]
Well, inb4 shitstorm/red thumbs. This is why I believe in a God. Sorry but that's my true opinion.
#110 - N. Korean citizen (01/22/2013) [-]
what this post fails to observe is the setting. think about this: the average human being does not think about a worm on the ground because worms are commonplace here on earth. worms, however are not commonplace outside of the earth (as far as we know), so if scientists found a worm on pluto they sure as fuck would be interested in it.

if an alien species found earth, I'm sure the mere fact that is is inhabited by such a diverse amount of living organisms would make them stop. especially considering the human race. anyone who thinks that humans are stupid or we do not mean anything, think of all we have accomplished. we are conscious, sentient beings (the only kind we know of) and we have defined laws that govern the universe.

i once saw an image that told of what to do if you were the one to make first contact with aliens. one of the first things it said to do was draw and label an example of the pythagorean theory, as a species as advanced enough to contact us would understand such physical and mathematical laws. we may not understand how everything in the universe works, but we sure as hell understand some things, enough, i think, to steal a glance from another intelligent race.
User avatar #115 to #110 - nadastress (01/22/2013) [-]
Actually this coincides more with superior beings not able to communicate. As the worm wouldn't be able to communicate with a microbe and so on. Get it?
#102 - xxgmanxx ONLINE (01/22/2013) [-]
Just wanted to post this image not much else to say.
User avatar #223 to #102 - dishesaredone (01/22/2013) [-]
My brother goes to Cornell
User avatar #96 - jokeface (01/22/2013) [-]
Dammit Tyson...you were this close to talking about God...THIS CLOSE.
User avatar #108 to #96 - anonymousattorney (01/22/2013) [-]
Well, if you want to relate this to God, then I suppose I could try my hand at it.
User avatar #95 - awesomenessdefined (01/22/2013) [-]
Or there are no aliens.

Let that sink in.
User avatar #105 to #95 - anonymouzx (01/22/2013) [-]
Says E.T
User avatar #107 to #105 - awesomenessdefined (01/22/2013) [-]
Nicholas Cage
User avatar #103 to #95 - xxgmanxx ONLINE (01/22/2013) [-]
In a world as small as ours it would be ridiculous to believe that we are the only ones out there in this forever expanding universe.
#106 to #103 - awesomenessdefined (01/22/2013) [-]
But not impossible.
But not impossible.
User avatar #97 to #95 - pseudobob (01/22/2013) [-]
There are two possibilities; We are alone, or we are not. These concepts are both terrifying.
User avatar #98 to #97 - awesomenessdefined (01/22/2013) [-]
The first one isn't.
#109 to #98 - N. Korean citizen (01/22/2013) [-]
The concept That There is no other planet in the universe that is capable of sustaining life isnt terrifying, the fact that either all planets capable met with a horrible end and is no longer capable, or the fact that Earth is the sole planet capable of sustaining life.
This is terrifying to me, because what happens on the point in which earth has no more resources for us to use, Whether though a natural disaster or though the natural parasitic tendency of humans.
If we are alone, Human days are numbered, or legacy meaningless, no more then one more grain in time, our entire race only purpose to destroy the only life giving planet.
User avatar #112 to #109 - awesomenessdefined (01/22/2013) [-]
There's a thing called terraforming. You make a planet capable of sustaining life. With Mars for example, you would have to heat up the atmosphere, release the carbon dioxide from the ice caps, create an ozone layer, plant vegetation, and wait for it to become earth like. So we can just go from planet to planet until the stars burn out.
User avatar #99 to #98 - pseudobob (01/22/2013) [-]
no stop

I think I butchered this quote from George Orwell. At any rate, yes, it is.
User avatar #101 to #99 - awesomenessdefined (01/22/2013) [-]
Not at all.
#94 - N. Korean citizen (01/22/2013) [-]
To anyone who says that it's different because humans are somewhat intelligent/have the ability to communicate/aren't governed completely by instinct should think about it a little differently. If the worm cannot comprehend human thought processes, than how can we comprehend and advances species thought processes? If worms understood our thought processes, than you would see worms, or any animal really, using forms of technology and advanced forms of communication. If we were to understand why these higher beings have no interest in us, it may be because we can't comprehend why. We're like the kid with a mental disability that doesn't understand why he has to keep his pants up while he uses the urinal.
#93 - imonaboatman (01/22/2013) [-]
Honestly, if I were another species passing by Earth and knew what its people were like, I'd overlook it as well. We are pretty damn retarded, as a whole.   
   
And there's BILLIONS of other planets out there. To say we're the only species is incredibly ignorant.
Honestly, if I were another species passing by Earth and knew what its people were like, I'd overlook it as well. We are pretty damn retarded, as a whole.

And there's BILLIONS of other planets out there. To say we're the only species is incredibly ignorant.
#91 - themoe (01/22/2013) [-]
If there were aliens close enough for us to observe than the theory would hold. But the smallest signs of life we've observed are many light years away meaning that if there are aliens out there (which we cant observe by this point because the distance). They wouldn't be able to conclude correctly weather we have intelligent lifeform or not. They would be seeing the earth with dinosaurs or even earlier than that.

So we just have to wait.... couple of million-billions of years
 Friends (0)