Pretty much my exact experience.
As I first started playing my initial opinion was that the game was overhyped as **** and full of hipster retro designs and **** .

Now I can't stop listening to the soundtrack and wanting to see more of all these characters I've become so emotionally attached to. Attached to in such a way I haven't felt in ******* years.

And it makes me sad because it makes me feel like I may never see or feel anything like this game again.