Login or register
Anonymous comments allowed.
#97 - isenseven
Reply +2 123456789123345869
(02/18/2013) [-]
User avatar #99 to #97 - deathzor
Reply -1 123456789123345869
(02/19/2013) [-]
'Cept that album was terrible in comparison to Images And Words...
User avatar #109 to #99 - darksideofthebeast
Reply 0 123456789123345869
(04/11/2013) [-]
I just farted really loud at your comment.
User avatar #111 to #109 - deathzor
Reply 0 123456789123345869
(04/16/2013) [-]
Quick question:

lurk much?
User avatar #112 to #111 - darksideofthebeast
Reply 0 123456789123345869
(04/16/2013) [-]
I browse the metal channel
User avatar #113 to #112 - deathzor
Reply 0 123456789123345869
(04/16/2013) [-]
You browse the metal channel and reply to two month old comments.

Or, is that a pun on the posting frequency on the metal channel?
User avatar #102 to #99 - davidokuro
Reply +1 123456789123345869
(02/24/2013) [-]
The only album you could justify calling terrible in comparison to their others is Black Clouds and Silver Linings. A Dramatic Turn of Events was actually really good.
User avatar #103 to #102 - deathzor
Reply 0 123456789123345869
(02/24/2013) [-]
I agree with you in saying Black Clouds was a bad album, but the fact that the mix for A Dramatic Turn was honky and Mike's drums were damn flat is just ******. Seriously. I will punch whoever mixed the album if I ever meet him.

That said, it wasn't a complete disappointment. I got to hear James' voice and how much better it's gotten over the years.

John Petrucci.....his distorted guitar tone was kinda awful but his playing was nice.

John Myung; well, his bass was audible.

Jordan was Jordan.

Mike and his recessed drums.....it left me wanting more in terms of production quality.
User avatar #104 to #103 - davidokuro
Reply -1 123456789123345869
(02/24/2013) [-]
That was Mikes first album with them though. Give him some time, you and I both know how nuts of a drummer mike can be, and I think a lot of that came through in Breaking All Illusions. The music is timed very strangely, but they still sound tight playing it. Bridges in the Sky is also a good example of the album. Of course, it is not as good as their other albums, but I still can't say it was disappointing. As far as the mix goes, I'll agree that it was pretty bland.
User avatar #105 to #104 - deathzor
Reply 0 123456789123345869
(02/24/2013) [-]
I'm not at all blaming Mike for how his drums sounded. I'm fairly certain JP was the one who produced the record, so I guess he was responsible; I'll slap his hands if I ever meet him, tell him, "NO, YOU WILL NOT TOUCH!".
User avatar #110 to #105 - darksideofthebeast
Reply 0 123456789123345869
(04/11/2013) [-]
And he would probably just look at you
With a death stare
as you die
from death stare.
#106 to #105 - isenseven
Reply +1 123456789123345869
(02/25/2013) [-]
I'd have to disagree with you completely.

In my opinion, their worst album to date was Train of Thought. And it's not even a bad album, just in comparison to all their other albums, there wasn't enough variety. This Dying Soul and In the Name of God are some of my favourite tracks, however.

But Black Clouds & Silver Linings and A Dramatic Turn of Events are in my top 5 Dream Theater albums, also in there are Images And Words, Systematic Chaos, and Scenes from a Memory.

Black Clouds has so many amazing tracks on it that it totally makes up for the genericness of "whither". A Nightmare To Remember, The Shattered Fortress, The Best of Times, and ESPECIALLY The Count of Tuscany are all 10/10 epics in my opinion.

And same goes for A Dramatic Turn. Every track on there serves its purpose and is beautifully original and epic. On The Backs of Angels, Lost Not Forgotten, This is The Life, Bridges in The Sky, Outcry, and Breaking All Illusions all sound completely original and tell their own epic story. The only song on that album I wouldn't give 10/10 to is Build Me Up, Break Me Down because it just doesn't hold as much originality as the other tracks do.

Perhaps my opinion is completely biased, because A Dramatic Turn was my first Dream Theater album, and I fell in love with every track on there, but perhaps that also makes me unbiased as well, because, at the time of listening to it, the name "Mike Portnoy" meant absolutely nothing to me. And being a Jazz and Theory nut, all of the songs appealed to me composition and performance wise.
User avatar #107 to #106 - deathzor
Reply 0 123456789123345869
(02/25/2013) [-]
I've been listening to DT since Six Degrees came out, and I immediately went back to Images and Words [since the first record sounds like shit] and fell in love.

Train of Thought was a pretty bad album, but it still has tracks that I like:

Stream of Consciousness, Endless Sacrifice, In The Name of God, and Honor Thy Father.

My opinion is sort of biased in the sense that I don't think DT will MY DT without Mike Portnoy, but as long as they're continuing to make good music, that's all that matters.

Looking back at Black Clouds, I suppose it's kinda dumb for me to say it was a bad album, but then again, I'm buttmad that my favorite band lost one of it's founding members.

The Shattered Fortress and The Best of Times are my favorite tracks off the album, and I'm going to learn Fortress as my first seven string track if I ever get hold of a decent seven string guitar.

Compared to Images and Words + Metropolis Pt.2, nothing is as great.

User avatar #108 to #107 - isenseven
Reply +1 123456789123345869
(02/25/2013) [-]
Well whatever, it doesn't matter which albums are good and which aren't as good. Every album they've come out with are amazing.

I also do like their first album, though. It has a basement-band sound, which is kind of a turn off, yet there's such amazing playing on it, it's ridiculous.