I HAVE THE BIGGEST CRUSH ON DAVID TENNANT. Also Martin Freeman, but that has nothing to do with anything, other than the fact that they're both 41. I like me some older men.
Rose:
Cons:
Romatic drama no one cared about. Wouldn't shut up. Wasted one of the doctor's lives.
Got herself in danger and really didn't do anthing.
Cons: Rose if she was black and the doctor didn't want to hit it.
Pro: Did more than rose.
Donna:
Cons:
Loudest. Had no ******* clue what so ever.
Pros: Did more than the other two. You actually sorta cared about her arc. Apparently a vital part of the doctor's existance.
Amy: Cons: More B.S. Doctor Romance drama, except she was quite the bitch.
Pros:
Did more than the first two, but not as much as donna. Part the epic arc of river song.
wow you suck at this pro/con thing, I read your comment, tried to understand it and I'm still not quite sure any of the things you say even remotely relate to the show.
*Ma'am. And since it's an opinion, not a fact, it cannot by definition BE wrong. But I'm going to assume you're a fellow Whovian, and the last thing I want to do is fight with you! Who's your favorite? =D
Well Mad'am , I respect your choice to not get in a fight on the internet. However Donna is just terrible and that's a fact. I would have to put my vote towards Amy & Rory.
Love Amy and Rory, Rory particularly! They're my second choice, honestly. I just really enjoyed Donna's repartee with the Doctor, and she's an amazing actress and comedian. I hated her at first, but definitely grew to love her and her story.
Well on a completely different subject here, I think they should make a mini series of Rory the Roman's adventures guarding the Pandorica through the years that Amy was inside it.
That would be so awesome!!!! Did you ever see the mini-ep of the letter Rory sent to his dad from the past? It's voiced by Arthur Darvill, and it's absolutely fabulous.
An opinion can of course be wrong when it is demonstrably at odds with reality.
"The moon is made of green cheese." is an opinion, after all.
Having said that, seeing as there is no exact model to determine the value of Dr. Who companions, this is a matter where your guess is as good as mine, yes.
Rose was best of all since '05, though.