Upload
Login or register
x
Anonymous comments allowed.
97 comments displayed.
User avatar #1060486 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
I was looking at the anime wiki page and I noticed that there is no Notable Light Novels section, how come?
User avatar #1060615 to #1060486 - thekame (10/19/2014) [-]
>notable light novels
User avatar #1060547 to #1060486 - Rei (10/19/2014) [-]
Because no Light Novel fan has made the page.
User avatar #1060549 to #1060547 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
I would if I knew how.
User avatar #1060552 to #1060549 - Rei (10/19/2014) [-]
good luck
User avatar #1060553 to #1060552 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
Thanks. Could you possibly tell me how?
User avatar #1060555 to #1060553 - Rei (10/19/2014) [-]
I did the VN one, now guess how I did that without knowing how to do it.
User avatar #1060557 to #1060555 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
What is Google?
User avatar #1060560 to #1060557 - Rei (10/19/2014) [-]
Copy pasted code from the anime one and changed the colour and category names.
User avatar #1060565 to #1060560 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
All right, I will make the page now.
User avatar #1060536 to #1060486 - killerliquid (10/19/2014) [-]
I'd rather them asking for recommendations since most are shit.
All You Need is Kill
Utsuro no Hako
Kino no Tabi
Spice and Wolf
AnoHana
Toradora
Baccano/Durarara
Fate Zero (really the anime would be better for the fights)

There's some more but it's basically those. You're not gonna get much better than the mainstream ones.
#1060580 to #1060536 - desmondxburton (10/19/2014) [-]
You forgot about nuclear magic Jesus
User avatar #1060583 to #1060580 - killerliquid (10/19/2014) [-]
I left it out on purpose

I love the magic explanations but they really aren't needed for the story at all
User avatar #1060595 to #1060583 - desmondxburton (10/19/2014) [-]
It is needed because they act like magic is more of a science than some unexplained force, so they can't just use the excuse of "because it's magic". I do think that it could be less wordy though.
User avatar #1060597 to #1060595 - killerliquid (10/19/2014) [-]
Yes but there's literally no need to do it everytime new magic shows up.

It wouldn't be so bad if the characters made explanations but it's written as the narrator makes them.
User avatar #1060618 to #1060597 - desmondxburton (10/19/2014) [-]
I can see why that could annoy someone, I guess it just doesn't bother me much.
User avatar #1060619 to #1060618 - killerliquid (10/19/2014) [-]
It didn't bother me either

I just recognize it
User avatar #1060537 to #1060536 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
I still say we should have the section on the wiki though.
User avatar #1060538 to #1060537 - killerliquid (10/19/2014) [-]
Nah
1. www.funnyjunk.com/anime/1060510#1060510
2. They could visit Baka-Tsuki since they know how to find it
3. relating to 1. they can google the names of whatever is on Baka-tsuki for more information
4. LNs are not as easy to get into as anime/manga
5. when a person decides to get into Japanese media they'd go for the more popular forms, Light novels would never pique the interest of one who is on an english forum
6. Overall it's a waste of time. I would rather link this thread to those random outliers who come here asking for LN recs
User avatar #1060593 to #1060538 - alhiniath (10/19/2014) [-]
Well LN's are just normal books. With the expection of it having art and that art being very japanease.
User avatar #1060596 to #1060593 - killerliquid (10/19/2014) [-]
Pretty much
User avatar #1060527 to #1060524 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
What's to say I don't read real books?
User avatar #1060515 to #1060486 - juon (10/19/2014) [-]
besides the fact that most have stories that are subpar at best
most of them have writing thats no better than a fourth graders essay assignment
User avatar #1060520 to #1060515 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
Some of them have some really good stories.
User avatar #1060530 to #1060520 - juon (10/19/2014) [-]
plus most still don't have writing thats all that great anyway
User avatar #1060529 to #1060520 - juon (10/19/2014) [-]
they really dont
only ones i can think of with a story that is at least decent are
baccano
durarara
densetsu no yuusha no densetsu
slayers
guin saga
fate zero
log horizon
monogatari
katanagatari
remembrances for a certain pilot
code geass
and hyouka

and with over 130 existing its a poor ratio for good:bad
granted its not as poor as the ratio for the other forms of media
but its still bad regardless
User avatar #1060531 to #1060529 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
You should add High School DxD to that list.
User avatar #1060533 to #1060531 - juon (10/19/2014) [-]
i would if it actually was
User avatar #1060535 to #1060533 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
How is not good?
User avatar #1060539 to #1060535 - juon (10/19/2014) [-]
lost what it couldve been due to the generic harem stuff going on
it couldve been something good that could be taken seriously like fate stay night
but the focus on comedy and ecchi undermines it
theres just too much of it and its all unneeded
User avatar #1060540 to #1060539 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
But unlike other harem/ecchi it actually has a plot to.
User avatar #1060546 to #1060540 - juon (10/19/2014) [-]
all other harem or ecchi light novels have some form of a plot to them
none of them are good
this is no exception
User avatar #1060548 to #1060546 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
Unlike other harem/ecchi I have read I actually enjoy this plot.
User avatar #1060554 to #1060548 - juon (10/19/2014) [-]
and i enjoyed the prequel trilogy for star wars
they sure arent good
same for haganai and bayonetta
User avatar #1060566 to #1060554 - yeorgh (10/19/2014) [-]
>Bayonetta

What?
User avatar #1060556 to #1060554 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
I actually enjoyed the second and third prequel movies.
User avatar #1060561 to #1060556 - juon (10/19/2014) [-]
but they still arent good
the writing for them just isnt that great
sure they expanded on how the empire came to be
and they had mace windu
but thats just about it
User avatar #1060570 to #1060561 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
I just thought that they were to CGI heavy.
User avatar #1060575 to #1060570 - juon (10/19/2014) [-]
that was part of it
but not the main problem with them
User avatar #1060577 to #1060575 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
For me that was my only gripe.
User avatar #1060608 to #1060577 - juon (10/19/2014) [-]
another problem
qui gon jinn discovered a way to keep ones identity by living on within the force itself
thats how obi wan and yodi were seen at the end of six
but then anakin somehow appeared the same way
even though qui gon never taught him how to do so
User avatar #1060601 to #1060577 - juon (10/19/2014) [-]
if they hadnt included the chosen one deal and midi-chlorians they wouldve been better
and if anakin was shown to be less caring from the beginning for others that werent padme
that caring side of him didnt coincide with his role as darth vader later and in theory would have shown more often while he was vader than it did
User avatar #1060607 to #1060601 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
Wasn't the chosen one bit in the original trilogy as well?
User avatar #1060620 to #1060607 - juon (10/19/2014) [-]
it wasnt stated in the movie itself
it was in a part of a book where it had some events from the movie in it
User avatar #1060621 to #1060620 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
I guess my research is wrong then.
User avatar #1060614 to #1060607 - juon (10/19/2014) [-]
it wasnt mentioned in the movie though
it was mentioned in page 210 of the life and legacy of obi wan kenobi
that page being right after anakin killed sidious
User avatar #1060617 to #1060614 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
According to my research it is in the movie when Vader kills Sidious.
User avatar #1060612 to #1060609 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
I just looked it up; it was first mentioned in Return of the Jedi.
User avatar #1060600 to #1060577 - taokami (10/19/2014) [-]
That was your only gripe with the prequel movies? What about, oh I don't know, midi-chlorians? Fucking little cells are the reason why people can use the force, how fucking retarded.
User avatar #1060603 to #1060600 - juon (10/19/2014) [-]
live symbiotically that is
User avatar #1060602 to #1060600 - juon (10/19/2014) [-]
intelligent microscopic cells that symbiotically inside the cells of all living things
worst part is that anakin was believed to have been conceived by the midi-chlorians themselves
User avatar #1060604 to #1060602 - taokami (10/19/2014) [-]
How absolutely fucking retarded, so Anakin is basically Evil Jesus. Greeaaaat.
User avatar #1060606 to #1060604 - juon (10/19/2014) [-]
evil jesus whos son became the real jesus
User avatar #1060510 to #1060486 - desmondxburton (10/19/2014) [-]
Because people who read LNs have probably been around anime and manga long enough to find shit on their own, and it is also the least popular form of media.
User avatar #1060514 to #1060510 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
So people are still reading it. I actually just got into light novels and more people might get into them as well.
User avatar #1060532 to #1060514 - desmondxburton (10/19/2014) [-]
But most translated LNs are really easy to find as most of them are on baka-tsuki. Baka-tsuki also already has LN recs as well, so if you want to do something for LN readers just post a link to there on the wiki. Also I recemond you read Utsuro no Hako to Zero no Maria, if you haven't already.
User avatar #1060534 to #1060532 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
I will read it when I get done with what I am currently reading.
0
#1060490 to #1060486 - tallzed has deleted their comment [-]
User avatar #1060488 to #1060486 - boyddamilkman (10/19/2014) [-]
LNs are generally shit.
User avatar #1060492 to #1060488 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
Have you actually read one?
User avatar #1060495 to #1060493 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
Which one?
User avatar #1060501 to #1060495 - boyddamilkman (10/19/2014) [-]
A fair amount, most are just very poorly written. Also there's a ton of harem trash there, more than anime or manga.
User avatar #1060504 to #1060501 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
Some are very well written though, like High School DxD.
User avatar #1060605 to #1060504 - alhiniath (10/19/2014) [-]
They have a good story, but they aren't well written. It's way better written than SAO for sure. Might just be because a lot of the prose is lost in translation because Fantranslation, but as a writer myself, the prose for most VN's are utterly fucking terrible.

User avatar #1060509 to #1060508 - boyddamilkman (10/19/2014) [-]
I make an argument that there is too much haremshit in LNs. Your example of a well written LN is haremshit.
User avatar #1060512 to #1060509 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
Sure he has a harem but he actually chooses one , also the way the author blends the different religions is very well executed.
User avatar #1060516 to #1060512 - yeorgh (10/19/2014) [-]
Last I heard it was a harem ending with Rias as the main girl.
User avatar #1060518 to #1060516 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
Nope, he chooses Rias though.
User avatar #1060519 to #1060518 - yeorgh (10/19/2014) [-]
She's crap.
User avatar #1060521 to #1060519 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
How so?
User avatar #1060522 to #1060521 - yeorgh (10/19/2014) [-]
She's too bland, at least from what i saw on the anime, Akeno is much better.
#1060542 to #1060522 - desmondxburton (10/19/2014) [-]
I completely agree with you, and don't listen to the other guy. He does choose Rias as the main girl, but she knows she has to share him with the other girls, so its still gonna have a harem ending.
I completely agree with you, and don't listen to the other guy. He does choose Rias as the main girl, but she knows she has to share him with the other girls, so its still gonna have a harem ending.
#1061965 to #1060542 - anon (10/22/2014) [-]
Source of the dancing girl gif please
#1062656 to #1061965 - desmondxburton (10/23/2014) [-]
High School DxD season 2 OP
High School DxD season 2 OP
User avatar #1060543 to #1060542 - yeorgh (10/19/2014) [-]
Nice.
User avatar #1060525 to #1060522 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
Her character gets more development later on in the novels.
User avatar #1060487 to #1060486 - yeorgh (10/19/2014) [-]
There's a real small amount of people who read manga here and a even smaller group that read LNs, hell i can't even think of 3 people who read LNs.
User avatar #1060502 to #1060487 - newbrony (10/19/2014) [-]
Even if there are few of us, we demand equal rights!

#lightnovelGate
User avatar #1060541 to #1060502 - juon (10/19/2014) [-]
the harem justice warriors dont know what theyre talking about
User avatar #1060523 to #1060502 - taokami (10/19/2014) [-]
> Light Nover

Read a real book.
User avatar #1060517 to #1060502 - tormain (10/19/2014) [-]
#Readingisradical
User avatar #1060507 to #1060502 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
I am with you!
#lightnovelGate
User avatar #1060503 to #1060502 - yeorgh (10/19/2014) [-]
No, go away.
User avatar #1060505 to #1060503 - newbrony (10/19/2014) [-]
Get a load of this guy's privilege.
User avatar #1060511 to #1060505 - yeorgh (10/19/2014) [-]
Well manga readers are master race.
User avatar #1060545 to #1060511 - newbrony (10/19/2014) [-]
Joking brah, I'm a swole mangagsta myself, but I love me a light novel from time to time.

The writing is usually pretty bad, but they have some cool ideas I can enjoy, especially if they don't get anime/manga adaptations.
#1060499 to #1060487 - anon (10/19/2014) [-]
heh heh

"manga here"
User avatar #1060500 to #1060499 - yeorgh (10/19/2014) [-]
Yes, hilarious.
User avatar #1060489 to #1060487 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
I read them. I think it might be useful to have it on there though.
User avatar #1060494 to #1060491 - tallzed (10/19/2014) [-]
It could even just link to the baka-tsuki website.
 Friends (0)