Lets be honest here, the first person doesn't need a beard and would look better without it. He's got a girly boy facial structure and when even your expense model lighting, cameras, and photoshop won't even mask that it's just sad because the beard is contradictory and pointless. At that point you're in the uncanney valley. No, you cannot be Justin Beiber and Ron Swanson at the same time: Play to your strengths.

Second Dude? Ugly ************ with a weak jaw yet wide face, but that means he has something to mask by it. He needs that beard, but what he really needs is to take care of it better. And at least he has the merit of not sporting it for douchey hipster reasons that you see with increasing prevalence now-a-days.